Articles · Vol. 2 No. 9 (2026)

Grammarians Differ On The Regent Governing The Mubtada (Subject) And Khabar (Predicate)

Authors

  • Samariddin AHMEDOV

Keywords

Arabic grammar nahw mubtada khabar regent (omil) nominative (rafʻ) predication (isnad) al-Zamakhshari al-Mufassal al-Khwarizmi al-Jandi Basran school Kufan school

Abstract

This article offers a comparative analysis of the views of medieval Arabic grammarians on one of the contested questions of syntax (nahw): the regent (omil) that governs the nominative case (rafʻ) of the mubtada (subject) and the khabar (predicate). It sets out the three positions on the question – those of the Basran school, of Sibawayh and of the Kufan school – and then examines in detail al-Zamakhshariʼs Basran formulation in al-Mufassal, together with the critical commentaries of Qasim al-Khwarizmi and Taj al-Din al-Jandi on that work and al-Jandiʼs logical refutation of the Kufan theory of “mutual requirement.” The article shows that the question rests not only on grammatical but also on logical and philosophical foundations, and that the commentary (sharh) tradition served not merely to explain but also to generate new scholarly ideas.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

1. Ahmad Nasr, A. H. (1998). Al-Mufassal asarining ism boʻlimi (al-Sananganiy sharhi asosida) [The nominal section of al-Mufassal (based on al-Sananqaniʼs commentary)] [Doctoral dissertation]. Umm al-Qura University.

2. al-Anbari, Abu al-Barakat. (2009). Al-Insaf fi masaʼil al-khilaf [The equitable resolution of disputed questions]. Maktabat al-Khanji.

3. al-Astarabadi, R. M. ibn al-Hasan. (1971). Sharh Kafiyat Ibn al-Hajib [Commentary on Ibn al-Hajibʼs al-Kafiya]. Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyya.

4. al-Jami, N. A. (2015). Al-Fawaʼid al-Diyaʼiyya [The Diyaʼi benefits]. Author.

5. al-Jandi, T. A. ibn Mahmud. (2002). Al-Iqlid fi sharh al-Mufassal [The key: a commentary on al-Mufassal]. King Fahd National Library.

6. al-Khwarizmi, Q. ibn al-Husayn (Sadr al-Afadil). (1990). Al-Takhmir (Vol. 1). Dar al-Gharb al-Islami.

7. al-Rajihi, A. (1980). Durus fi al-madhahib al-nahwiyya [Lessons on the grammatical schools]. Dar al-Nahda al-Arabiyya.

8. Rashid Ahmad, M. (2004). Maʻarif al-Kafiya wa-ʻawarif al-Jami. Al-Madrasa al-Arabiyya Qasim al-Ulum.

9. Sibawayh, A. B. Amr ibn Uthman ibn Qanbar. (1988). Al-Kitab [The book]. Cairo.

10. al-Zamakhshari, A. M. ibn Umar. (2004). Al-Mufassal fi ulum al-arabiyya [The detailed work on the Arabic sciences]. Dar Ammar. 463 E-ISSN 3069-8375